- Date: 05/09/09
- Location: Indiana Wesleyan - Marion, IN
-
- ICON KEY:
| Place | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score |
| 1. | Chege, Samuel | Goshen | 1:56.51 | - | ||
| 2. | Foss, Josh | Indiana Wesleyan | 1:57.82 | - | ||
| 3. | Thelen, Nick | Aquinas | 1:57.99 | - | ||
| 4. | Vereecke, Andy | Aquinas | 1:58.25 | - | ||
| 5. | Heiler, Dustin | Aquinas | 1:58.28 | - | ||
| 6. | Kirsch, Nathan | Taylor | 1:59.15 | - | ||
| 7. | Heyboer, Keith | Davenport | 1:59.91 | - | ||
| 8. | Tencher, Brian | Taylor | 2:00.99 | - | ||
| 9. | Haller, Matthias | Huntington | 2:01.36 | - | ||
| 10. | Stickney, Kolin | Aquinas | 2:02.03 | - | ||
| 11. | Schweigert, Josh | Indiana Wesleyan | 2:03.83 | - | ||
| 12. | Rumsey, David | Goshen | 2:05.42 | - |