- Date: 01-23-10
- Location: Baldwin-Wallace-Lou Higgins Center - Brea, OH
-
- ICON KEY:
| Place | Overall | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score |
| 1. | 1 | Zeuch, James | JR-3 | Malone | 4:15.88 | - | |
| 2. | 2 | Dipre, Tony | SR-4 | Allegheny | 4:16.32 | - | |
| 3. | 3 | Sinick, Christopher | SR-4 | Malone | 4:16.57 | - | |
| 4. | 4 | Griffin, Ty | JR-3 | Mount Union | 4:18.00 | - | |
| 5. | 5 | Kelly, Tim | SO-2 | Mount Union | 4:22.01 | - | |
| 6. | 6 | Hanson, Ryan | SR-4 | Allegheny | 4:25.14 | - | |
| 7. | 7 | Ross, Zac | JR-3 | Allegheny | 4:27.86 | - | |
| 8. | 8 | Vlah, Mike | FR-1 | Allegheny | 4:29.37 | - | |
| 9. | 9 | Pulley, Bryce | FR-1 | Malone | 4:29.47 | - | |
| 10. | 10 | Wilkin, Thomas | Baldwin-Wallace College | 4:29.88 | - | ||
| 11. | 11 | Lancaster, Cody | FR-1 | Lake Erie | 4:34.77 | - | |
| 12. | 12 | Burns, Pat | FR-1 | John Carroll | 4:39.79 | - | |
| 13. | 13 | Smith, Jake | SO-2 | John Carroll | 4:41.35 | - | |
| 14. | 16 | Janosko, Kenneth | Baldwin-Wallace College | 4:50.74 | - |