| Place | Overall | Team | Squad | Athletes | Time | Score |
| 1. | 11 | Hillsdale | A | Jared Krout, Skylar Dooley, Nick Galvan, Michael Finch | 3:31.72 | - | |
| 2. | 12 | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | A | Jeremiah Tworek, Joe Tooks, Tyler Sult, Tadd Hettinger | 3:32.11 | - |
| Place | Overall | Team | Squad | Athletes | Time | Score |
| 1. | 4 | Cedarville | A | Brandon Tress, Justin Hoffman, Michael Beight, Samuel Starr | 3:23.87 | 5 | |
| 2. | 5 | Lake Erie | A | Quinton Harley, Jason Vitek, Donta Covington, Ethan Snyder | 3:25.92 | 4 | |
| 3. | 6 | Notre Dame (Ohio) | A | Brandon Tolliver, Joseph Leyland, Tom Gay, Demar Sheffey | 3:27.25 | 3 | |
| 4. | 8 | Lewis | A | Donnie Lesnick, Chris Leibrand, Robert Robinson, Aaron Jett | 3:28.07 | 1 | |
| 5. | 10 | Saginaw Valley | A | Tony Filipek, Marion Body, Charlie Richards, Scott Chevalier | 3:29.59 | - |
| Place | Overall | Team | Squad | Athletes | Time | Score |
| 1. | 1 | Findlay | A | Greg Schaible, Curtis Smithey, Shawnathan Fort, Simon Bernard | 3:19.31 | 10 | |
| 2. | 2 | Lincoln (Mo.) | A | Dwain Bryden, Steve Banton, Sabiel Anderson, Rupert Smith | 3:21.63 | 8 | |
| 3. | 3 | Ashland | A | Cory Lamar, Alan Dunson, Wesley Washington, Joe Horn | 3:23.25 | 6 | |
| 4. | 7 | Grand Valley St. | A | Michael Bareman, Jared Meier, Craig Rumpf, Eric Lowe | 3:27.26 | 2 | |
| 5. | 9 | Seton Hill | A | Jonathan Dennis, Chris Bartko, Sean Randall, Josh Wilks | 3:28.44 | - | |
| 6. | Wheeling Jesuit | A | Shane Rabant, Travis Hamrick, Travis McKinley, Brandon McKinley | NT | - |