- Date: 01/20/12
- Location: St. Anthony's High School - South Huntington, NY
-
- ICON KEY:
| Place | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score |
| 1. | Forbes, Shamell | SR-4 | Stony Brook | 2:35.63 | - | |
| 2. | Snak, James | SO-2 | Stony Brook | 2:38.51 | - | |
| 3. | Johnson, Robert | FR-1 | St. Joseph's (L.I.) | 2:41.66 | - | |
| 4. | Tiernan, Sean | SR-4 | Farmingdale St. | 2:44.96 | - | |
| 5. | Perez, Josh | SO-2 | Manhattan | 2:46.40 | - | |
| 6. | Frederic, William | FR-1 | Farmingdale St. | 2:52.86 | - | |
| 7. | Ellison, Skylar | FR-1 | St. Joseph's (L.I.) | 3:00.94 | - |