- Date: 01/20/12
- Location: St. Anthony's High School - South Huntington, NY
-
- ICON KEY:
- Mets
| Place | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score |
| 1. | Denis, Daniel | SO-2 | Stony Brook | 4:23.94 | - |
|
| 2. | Rammelkamp, Thomas | SR-4 | Stony Brook | 4:26.27 | - | |
| 3. | Williams, Geoffrey | Westchester TC | 4:27.19 | - | ||
| 4. | Chantry, Stephen | FR-1 | Manhattan | 4:39.61 | - | |
| 5. | Tiernan, Sean | SR-4 | Farmingdale St. | 4:40.04 | - | |
| 6. | Haslbauer, Eric | FR-1 | Molloy | 4:40.44 | - | |
| 7. | Pluhowski, Joe | SR-4 | Manhattan | 4:46.72 | - | |
| 8. | Ferraro, Steven | SO-2 | Molloy | 4:47.37 | - | |
| 9. | Francis, Peter | JR-3 | Queens (N.Y.) | 4:48.09 | - | |
| 10. | Merced, Zachary | Queensborough CC | 4:48.96 | - | ||
| 11. | Kramer, Peter | SO-2 | Queens (N.Y.) | 4:55.60 | - | |
| 12. | Cyrille, Nathan | Queensborough CC | 4:58.37 | - | ||
| 13. | Garcia, Michael | Nassau CC | 5:03.91 | - | ||
| 14. | Coba, David | Queensborough CC | 5:07.01 | - | ||
| 15. | Rivera, Travis | Queensborough CC | 5:20.89 | - | ||
| 16. | Alrubaye, Hisham | Queensborough CC | NT | - |