- Date: 2/3 - 02/04/12
- Location: Armory Track & Field Center - New York, NY
-
- ICON KEY:
| Place | Name | Year | Team | Time | Score |
| 1. | Mumba, Prince | Santa Monica Track Club | 1:48.56 | - | ||
| 2. | Mutekanga, Julius | C P T C New Balance | 1:48.63 | - | ||
| 3. | Jones, Rich | Santa Monica Track Club | 1:48.87 | - | ||
| 4. | Veras, Jose | Unattached | 1:51.41 | - | ||
| 5. | Bascom, Deon | N Y A C | 1:52.48 | - | ||
| 6. | Walsh, Aidan | N Y A C | 1:52.86 | - | ||
| 7. | Beauvais, Alie | Haiti | 1:53.16 | - | ||
| 8. | Oswald, Sean-Patrick | Greater Philadelphia TC | 1:53.32 | - | ||
| 9. | Reid, Nick | NY - NJ Track Club | 1:54.82 | - |