- Date: 02/17/12
- Location: St. Anthony's High School - South Huntington, NY
-
- ICON KEY:
| Place | Team | Squad | Athletes | Time | Score |
| 1. | St. Thomas Aquinas | A | George Erazo, Garvenchy Nicolas, Michael Kraus, Alex Andre | 8:17.82 | - | |
| 2. | Farmingdale St. | A | Sean Tiernan, Russell Darress, Eddie Lopez, William Frederic | 8:18.44 | - | |
| 3. | St. Thomas Aquinas | B | Frankie Colon, Matt Buell, Joe Chegwidden, Mike Galonski | 8:38.21 | - | |
| 4. | Queens (N.Y.) | A | Tyler Bay, Joseph Mayer, Andrew Mayer, Peter Kramer | 8:47.98 | - |