| 1) | Supino, Christina | Dartmouth | 2:07.25 (04/19-04/21) | 2:08.36 (05/05-05/06) | 2:09.19 (05/05-05/06) | |||
| 2) | Logan, Ne'Ausha | UCF | 2:07.25 (05/11-05/13) | 2:09.08 (05/11-05/13) | 2:12.89 (03/23-03/24) | 2:13.61 (04/06-04/07) | ||
| 3) | Elcock, Beverly | Eastern Michigan | 2:07.25 (05/10-05/12) | 2:09.42 (05/03-05/04) | 2:11.51 (04/20-04/21) | 2:11.52 (05/10-05/12) | 2:13.60 (04/13-04/14) | 2:13.86 (03/30-03/31) |