| 1) | Rohatinsky, Jared | BYU | 3:46.79 (04/25-04/28) | 3:48.04 (05/12) | 3:50.21 (03/23-03/24) | 3:50.38 (04/19-04/21) | 3:51.31 (04/06-04/07) | |
| 2) | Lapham, Charles | Drake | 3:46.79 (05/04) | 3:48.10 (04/21) | 3:51.55 (04/06) | 3:51.59 (05/11-05/13) | 3:52.93 (04/25-04/28) | 3:53.88 (03/30-03/31) |
| 3) | Kimeli, Patrick | Texas A&M-CC | 3:46.79 (05/11-05/13) | 3:49.03 (03/28-03/31) | 3:58.71 (03/17) | 4:00.55 (05/11-05/13) | ||
| 4) | Petrie, Charlie | Boise State | 3:46.79 (04/25-04/28) | 3:54.38 (05/09-05/12) | 3:57.06 (04/07) | 3:58.17 (03/30-03/31) |