| 1) | Golato, Andrew | Haverford | 1:51.59 (05/14) | 1:51.59 (05/14) | 1:51.82 (04/20-04/21) | 1:54.19 (05/04-05/06) | 1:54.78 (04/14) | 1:56.79 (05/04-05/06) |
| 2) | Tasco, Dominic | TCNJ | 1:51.59 (05/11-05/13) | 1:51.75 (04/20-04/21) | 1:52.25 (04/14) | 1:55.06 (05/05) | 1:55.87 (03/30-03/31) | 1:58.28 (05/17) |