| 1) | Alston, Bailey | Wis.-La Crosse | 5.65m (05/11) | 5.58m (05/17) | 5.55m (05/17) | 5.54m (05/04-05/05) | 5.51m (05/11) | 5.50m (05/04-05/05) | 5.50m (05/11) | 5.45m (05/17) |
| 2) | Bates, Naomi | Amherst | 5.65m (04/14) | 5.56m (05/03-05/05) | 5.56m (05/17-05/18) | 5.49m (05/17-05/18) | 5.45m (05/17-05/18) | 5.42m (05/10-05/12) | 5.40m (05/17-05/18) | 5.38m (05/17-05/18) |
| 3) | DeLude, Lauren | Utica | 5.65m (04/07) | 5.54m (04/07) | 5.44m (05/04-05/05) | 5.41m (04/07) | 5.41m (05/17-05/18) | 5.38m (05/17-05/18) | 5.23m (04/07) | 5.22m (05/04-05/05) |
| 4) | Diaz-Arrastia, Anne | Washington U. | 5.65m (05/15-05/18) | 5.47m (04/28-04/29) | 5.46m (04/28-04/29) | 5.41m (04/28-04/29) | 5.38m (05/15-05/18) | 5.18m (04/13-04/14) | 5.15m (04/13-04/14) | 5.09m (03/30-03/31) |
| 5) | Evans, Elizabeth | Rose-Hulman | 5.65m (04/07) | 5.44m (04/07) | 5.31m (04/07) | 5.28m (04/27-04/28) | 5.23m (03/30-03/31) | 5.22m (03/30-03/31) | 5.16m (03/30-03/31) | 5.15m (04/27-04/28) |