| 1) | Bennett, Michael | U. of Chicago | 4.70m (03/02) | 4.68m (02/16) | 4.68m (02/23-02/24) | 4.63m (02/23-02/24) | 4.59m (02/16) | 4.55m (03/02) | 4.48m (02/23-02/24) | 4.45m (02/01) |
| 2) | Lazor, Adam | Ramapo | 4.70m (02/22) | 4.67m (03/01-03/02) | 4.65m (12/08) | 4.55m (02/22) | 4.55m (02/01-02/02) | 4.52m (03/01-03/02) | 4.50m (01/25-01/26) | 4.40m (01/12) |
| 3) | Nakanishi, Brad | Tufts | 4.70m (01/12) | 4.67m (03/01-03/02) | 4.60m (01/26) | 4.60m (02/01-02/02) | 4.55m (02/15-02/16) | 4.52m (03/01-03/02) | ||
| 4) | Hardin-Wallace, Dan | Defiance | 4.70m (02/16) | 4.67m (01/26) | 4.55m (01/18) | 4.55m (02/16) | 4.55m (02/02) | 4.40m (01/18) | 4.40m (01/26) | 4.40m (02/02) |
| 5) | Crowson, Collin | Rose-Hulman | 4.70m (02/16) | 4.65m (01/26) | 4.63m (01/18) | 4.60m (01/12) | 4.60m (02/09) | 4.55m (02/22) | 4.55m (02/16) | 4.50m (01/26) |
| 6) | Alaniva, Nick | Washington U. | 4.70m (03/02) | 4.63m (02/23-02/24) | 4.55m (03/02) | 4.48m (02/23-02/24) | 4.47m (02/15) | 4.45m (02/09) | 4.40m (03/02) | 4.33m (02/23-02/24) |
| 7) | Bollinger, Conrad | Principia | 4.70m (03/02) | 4.62m (02/15) | 4.55m (03/02) | 4.47m (02/15) | 4.44m (02/02) | 4.42m (01/25) | 4.42m (02/22) | 4.40m (03/02) |
| 8) | Dickmann, Jake | Wis.-Oshkosh | 4.70m (03/02) | 4.58m (01/25) | 4.55m (03/02) | 4.52m (02/22-02/23) | 4.51m (02/16) | 4.47m (02/09) | 4.45m (01/18) | 4.45m (02/01) |