| 1) | Nysather, Jake | Monmouth (Ill.) | 52.47m (04/06) | 52.33m (05/04) | 52.06m (05/04) | 51.60m (04/20) | 51.25m (05/04) | 51.13m (05/17) | 51.11m (04/06) | 50.84m (05/04) |
| 2) | Faulhaber, Max | Willamette | 52.47m (04/06) | 52.09m (03/14) | 51.84m (04/06) | 51.57m (04/12) | 51.45m (03/14) | 51.22m (03/22-03/23) | 51.20m (03/08-03/09) | 51.11m (04/06) |