| 1) | Kemmerer, Katie | Marquette | 57.02 (02/07-02/08) | 57.04 (02/21-02/22) | 57.30 (01/24-01/25) | 57.56 (02/21-02/22) | 58.36 (12/06) | ||
| 2) | Abraham, Shannon | Duquesne | 57.02 (02/22-02/23) | 57.18 (02/22-02/23) | 58.16 (02/07-02/08) | 58.39 (01/31-02/01) | 58.74 (01/24) | 58.93 (01/11) | 59.41 (02/14-02/15) |
| 3) | Bedell, Corinn | Liberty | 57.02 (02/28-03/01) | 57.34 (02/28-03/01) | 57.48 (02/07-02/08) | 58.32 (12/04-12/05) | 58.74 (01/24-01/25) | 58.86 (01/17-01/18) | |
| 4) | Reid, Katherine | UCLA | 57.02 (02/07-02/08) | 57.94 (02/01) | |||||
| 5) | Osborne, Megan | Penn State | 57.02 (02/07-02/08) | 58.09 (02/14-02/15) | |||||
| 6) | Fair, Leah | Coastal Carolina | 57.02 (12/07) |