| 1) | Sustachek, Tony | Wis.-Milwaukee | 1:54.09 (03/01-03/02) | 1:54.85 (03/01-03/02) | 1:54.96 (02/07-02/08) | 1:55.19 (02/14-02/15) | 1:55.27 (01/25) |
| 2) | Franz, Brendan | Marquette | 1:54.09 (02/14-02/15) | 1:55.18 (02/21-02/22) | 1:56.39 (01/31-02/01) | ||
| 3) | Scharold, Robbie | Kentucky | 1:54.09 (02/07-02/08) |