| 1) | Bergevin, Bryce | Boise State | 1:54.21 (02/15) | 1:54.73 (02/27-03/01) | 1:54.83 (02/08) | ||
| 2) | Miklja, Zac | Michigan | 1:54.21 (02/22) | 1:55.01 (02/14-02/15) | |||
| 3) | Hamilton, Tyler | Central Michigan | 1:54.21 (02/01) | 1:55.06 (02/07) | 1:55.45 (02/21) | 1:56.45 (02/14-02/15) | 1:58.01 (01/17) |
| 4) | Pierce, Desmond | East Tenn. St. | 1:54.21 (02/21-02/22) | 1:55.94 (02/07-02/08) | 1:57.59 (01/11) | 1:58.03 (01/17-01/18) | 1:59.83 (01/31-02/01) |
| 5) | McAndrew, Bryce | North Texas | 1:54.21 (02/14) | 1:56.41 (01/25) | |||
| 6) | O'donoghue McDonald, Drew | Boise State | 1:54.21 (01/24-01/25) |