| 1) | Lafaver, Jake | Nazareth | 1:53.69 (03/07-03/08) | 1:53.91 (02/28-03/01) | 1:54.62 (02/21) | 1:56.82 (01/25) | 1:57.25 (02/01) |
| 2) | Vander Veer, Jamie | Central College | 1:53.69 (03/08) | 1:54.17 (02/28-03/01) | 1:54.70 (02/21) | 1:55.04 (02/15) | |
| 3) | Patterson, Spencer | St. Lawrence | 1:53.69 (02/28-03/01) | 1:55.35 (02/21) | 2:05.32 (02/01) |