| 1) | Rhodes, Jerome | Milwaukee Sch. of Eng. | 2.09m (03/01) | 2.08m (02/15) | 2.07m (02/01) | 2.05m (02/15) | 2.05m (02/01) | 2.03m (01/17-01/18) | 2.00m (02/01) | 2.00m (02/22) |
| 2) | Welshons, Nick | St. John's (Minn.) | 2.09m (03/06-03/08) | 2.07m (02/22) | 2.06m (03/06-03/08) | 2.05m (02/22) | 2.03m (03/06-03/08) | 2.00m (03/06-03/08) | 1.98m (02/22) | 1.97m (03/06-03/08) |
| 3) | Wukotich, Zach | Mount Union | 2.09m (02/28-03/01) | 2.06m (02/08) | 2.05m (02/01) | 2.03m (03/06) | 2.03m (02/28-03/01) | 2.01m (02/08) | 2.00m (02/28-03/01) | 1.99m (02/15) |
| 4) | Eddy, Brandon | Baldwin Wallace | 2.09m (02/28-03/01) | 2.06m (02/28-03/01) | 2.03m (02/28-03/01) | 2.00m (02/28-03/01) | 1.97m (02/08-02/09) | 1.97m (02/15) | 1.96m (02/28-03/01) | 1.94m (02/15) |