| 1) | Ciattei, Vincent | Virginia Tech | 3:45.28 (05/04) | 3:49.79 (04/17-04/19) | 3:51.08 (04/03-04/05) | 3:52.74 (04/17-04/19) |
| 2) | McFann, Harry | Columbia | 3:45.28 (05/02-05/03) | 3:52.77 (04/04-04/05) | ||
| 3) | Biekert, Brian | Central Connecticut | 3:45.28 (04/12-04/13) | 4:01.98 (05/03-05/04) | 4:13.50 (05/03-05/04) |