| 1) | Elam, Jeff | Eastern Michigan | 52.30 (05/15-05/17) | 52.70 (05/15-05/17) | 52.74 (05/03) | 52.92 (05/09) | 52.92 (05/09) | 52.95 (04/18-04/19) | 54.33 (04/04-04/05) | 55.66 (03/28-03/29) |
| 2) | Mulder, Joshua | Kennesaw State | 52.30 (05/16-05/17) | 52.99 (04/18-04/19) | 53.96 (03/21-03/22) | 54.53 (03/26-03/29) | 54.64 (04/03) |