| 1) | Sheppard, Carlton | Wesley | 1:52.41 (05/16) | 1:52.45 (05/12) | 1:52.68 (05/09) | 1:53.47 (05/03-05/04) | 1:54.32 (04/12) | 1:54.34 (04/22) | ||
| 2) | Kish, Zach | NYU | 1:52.41 (05/12) | 1:53.66 (04/12) | 1:53.75 (05/02-05/03) | 1:53.91 (05/16) | 1:54.46 (04/26-04/27) | 1:54.96 (04/26-04/27) | 1:54.99 (04/04-04/05) | 1:55.11 (04/18-04/19) |
| 3) | Rolph, Adam | Principia | 1:52.41 (05/08-05/09) | 1:53.70 (05/15-05/16) | 1:54.02 (04/18) | 1:55.49 (03/28-03/29) | 1:56.05 (04/05) | 1:56.49 (03/21) | 1:56.93 (05/03) | 1:57.50 (04/11-04/12) |