| 1) Wis.-Whitewater | 3:52.28 (04/23) | 3:52.40 (05/15) | 4:01.82 (05/02) | 4:03.58 (04/11) | 4:08.58 (04/17) | 4:09.24 (04/11) | 4:16.38 (04/06) | 4:22.16 (04/11) |
| 2) Nebraska Wesleyan | 3:52.28 (05/15) | 3:53.31 (04/23) | 3:54.30 (05/09) | 3:55.52 (05/02) | 4:04.34 (04/18) | 4:23.21 (04/18) |