| 1) | Vargas, Gerardo | Mount Union | 4.90m (04/25-04/26) | 4.90m (04/19) | 4.85m (04/19) | 4.80m (04/19) | 4.80m (04/25-04/26) | 4.76m (05/12-05/13) | 4.70m (04/25-04/26) | 4.70m (04/19) |
| 2) | Young, Trevor | Wabash | 4.90m (04/05) | 4.75m (04/05) | 4.75m (04/26) | 4.65m (04/26) | 4.60m (04/05) | 4.55m (05/02-05/03) | 4.46m (04/12) | 4.45m (04/26) |