| 1) | Frey, Lincoln | Trine | 4.70m (05/07-05/08) | 4.70m (04/24-04/26) | 4.70m (05/10) | 4.62m (05/16) | 4.60m (04/12) | 4.55m (04/24-04/26) | 4.55m (05/07-05/08) | 4.51m (04/18-04/19) |
| 2) | Giglio, Juan | TCNJ | 4.70m (04/12) | 4.65m (05/12) | 4.50m (05/12) | 4.34m (05/12) | 4.20m (05/03-05/04) | 4.05m (05/03-05/04) | ||
| 3) | Fox, Tim | Muskingum | 4.70m (04/25-04/26) | 4.60m (04/25-04/26) | 4.58m (04/12) | 4.45m (04/25-04/26) | 4.45m (05/02) | 4.43m (04/12) | 4.40m (03/29) | 4.40m (04/19) |
| 4) | Wolters, Lucas | Calvin | 4.70m (04/25-04/26) | 4.60m (05/01-05/02) | 4.55m (05/10) | 4.51m (04/18-04/19) | 4.50m (05/01-05/02) | 4.40m (04/12) | 4.40m (05/01-05/02) | 4.36m (04/18-04/19) |
| 5) | Polyte, Chandler | Illinois College | 4.70m (04/10-04/12) | 4.57m (04/18) | 4.55m (04/10-04/12) | 4.52m (05/15-05/16) | 4.50m (03/28-03/29) | 4.42m (04/18) | 4.40m (04/10-04/12) | 4.37m (05/15-05/16) |
| 6) | Patten, Luke | PSU-Behrend | 4.70m (05/09) | 4.56m (05/15-05/16) | 4.55m (05/09) | 4.50m (03/22) | 4.46m (05/12-05/13) | 4.41m (05/15-05/16) | 4.40m (04/19) | 4.40m (05/09) |