| 1. | 9. | Ashland | Va. Military Institute (B) | A | A | Elijha Owens, Waquiem Comar, Drew Windle, Jacob Cook | Jared Vega, Nathan Wright, Bradley Wisler, Jor-el Sanchez | 21:03:14.1737 | 35:03:28.823 | - | - |
| 2. | 25. | Tiffin | Duquesne | A | B | Lamar Hargrove, Dominic Colvin, Reginald Mortel, Ishan Garrett | Jacob Lysher, Quincy Murphy, Desmond Weinberg-Jones, Yol Ho Sung | 3:14.316 | 3:14.316 | - | 840 |
| 3. | 4. | Va. Military Institute | Duquesne (C) | A | A | Jordan Bailey, Brandon Hartman, Avery Martin, Julian Jackson | Nick Long, Corey King, Kyle Pane, Robert Shorthouse | 3:22.377 | 3:26.011 | 910 | - |
| 4. | 25. | Walsh | Va. Military Institute (C) | A | A | Craig Dougherty, Paul Sonego, Joseph Mikulin, Sherman Kortze | Marc-Daniel Julien, Owen Norley, Mike Standish, Thomas Vandenberg | 46:03:23.1309 | 46:03:23.1309 | - | - |
| 5. | 20. | Slippery Rock | Slippery Rock (B) | A | A | Hunter Williams, Trevor Foley, Nathaniel Helfferich, Jacob VanHouten | Jordan Hoppel, Brandon Freeman, Columbus Millet, Austin Hill | 3:24.145 | 56:03:40.6210 | - | - |
| 6. | 21. | Va. Military Institute (B) | Slippery Rock (B) | B | B | Jacob Lysher, Quincy Murphy, Desmond Weinberg-Jones, Yol Ho Sung | Jacob Lysher, Quincy Murphy, Desmond Weinberg-Jones, Yol Ho Sung | 3:26.011 | 56:03:40.6210 | 883 | 9356 |
| 7. | 9. | Ashland (C) | Wheeling Jesuit (B) | C | A | Joshua Davis, Nick Hall, Jacob Sussman, Zaan Janse | Jack Felt, Justin Elchynski, Paul Stults, Matt Guiod | 46:03:26.727 | 3:36.02 | - | - |
| 8. | 34. | Wheeling Jesuit | California (Pa.) | A | D | Marius Weber, Anthony Phillips, Travis McKinley, Michel Krempin | Jordan Bailey, Brandon Hartman, Avery Martin, Julian Jackson | 42:03:27.12 | 3:24.145 | - | - |
| 9. | 22. | Carnegie Mellon | Duquesne (B) | A | D | Marc-Daniel Julien, Owen Norley, Mike Standish, Thomas Vandenberg | Ronald Graf, Zach Perry, Frank Adamo, Matt Ridge | 37:03:27.74 | 3:38.05 | - | - |
| 10. | 8. | Ashland (B) | Slippery Rock (B) | B | B | Jordan Hoppel, Brandon Freeman, Columbus Millet, Austin Hill | Hunter Williams, Trevor Foley, Nathaniel Helfferich, Jacob VanHouten | 3:27.812 | 25:03:37.889 | - | - |
| 11. | 17. | Cedarville | Va. Military Institute | A | C | Matthew Bird, Tim Dejong, Andre Klassen, David Yoder | Anthony Yasko, Robert Brooks, Jake Dindak, Christian Friday | 3:28.42 | 38:03:34.9478 | - | 910 |
| 12. | 19. | Duquesne (B) | Washington and Jefferson | B | B | Mike Strein, Kyle Trinch, Tyler Pirilla, Mike Bryk | Lamar Hargrove, Dominic Colvin, Reginald Mortel, Ishan Garrett | 35:03:28.823 | 56:03:40.6210 | 6 | - |
| 13. | 19. | California (Pa.) | California (Pa.) (D) | A | D | Joe Vedilago, Francis Jajua, Aaron Morgan, Morgan Huegel | Brandon Simmons, Scott Whitaker, Mitch Williams, Jarod Williams | 3:29.0074 | 35:03:45.411 | - | - |
| 14. | 1. | Malone (B) | Va. Military Institute (C) | B | A | Brandon Simmons, Scott Whitaker, Mitch Williams, Jarod Williams | Andrew Bridgeforth, Monte Chapman, Brandon Vanderbrook, Derick Fiedler | 44:03:29.265 | 3:38.77 | - | 883 |
| 15. | 12. | Tiffin (B) | California (Pa.) (D) | B | A | Isaac Beverly, Shaun Borland, Macerio Clark, Austin Davis | Stephen Deak, Troy Zangaro, Joe Lynch, Jonathan Stiles | 3:30.2080 | 37:03:27.74 | - | - |
| 16. | 31. | Lock Haven | Va. Military Institute (B) | A | A | Jack Felt, Justin Elchynski, Paul Stults, Matt Guiod | Jared Vega, Nathan Wright, Bradley Wisler, Jor-el Sanchez | 54:03:31.053 | 21:03:14.1737 | - | - |
| 17. | 33. | Malone | Tiffin | A | C | Philip Palmer, Eric Barto, Marc Megenhardt, Matt Hendrix | Jordan Hoppel, Brandon Freeman, Columbus Millet, Austin Hill | 3:33.1522 | 3:41.9422 | - | 59 |
| 18. | 11. | Duquesne (C) | Wheeling Jesuit (B) | C | A | Patrick Miller, Carl Sturges, Paul Blinn, Frank Dallago | Jack Felt, Justin Elchynski, Paul Stults, Matt Guiod | 3:34.6655 | 25:03:37.889 | 59 | - |
| 19. | 13. | Cedarville (B) | Walsh | B | B | Corey Caldwell, Aaron Harkness, Phillip Lehman, Tucker Rhodes | Andrew Bridgeforth, Monte Chapman, Brandon Vanderbrook, Derick Fiedler | 3:34.78 | 17:03:47.128 | - | - |
| 20. | 12. | Indiana (Pa.) | Cedarville (B) | A | A | Stephen Deak, Troy Zangaro, Joe Lynch, Jonathan Stiles | Jared Vega, Nathan Wright, Bradley Wisler, Jor-el Sanchez | 38:03:34.9478 | 3:34.78 | - | - |
| 21. | 22. | California (Pa.) (B) | Carnegie Mellon | B | B | Antonio Casterlow, Keon Thompson, Savon Salter, Steven Stoffel | Jack Felt, Justin Elchynski, Paul Stults, Matt Guiod | 3:36.02 | 54:03:31.053 | - | - |
| 22. | 32. | Lock Haven (B) | Washington and Jefferson | B | A | Nick Long, Corey King, Kyle Pane, Robert Shorthouse | Brennan Comfort, Roland Rush, Brandon Porter, Jake Dull | 3:37.04 | 3:33.1522 | - | - |
| 23. | 5. | Slippery Rock (B) | Tiffin (B) | B | A | Andrew Bridgeforth, Monte Chapman, Brandon Vanderbrook, Derick Fiedler | Stephen Deak, Troy Zangaro, Joe Lynch, Jonathan Stiles | 25:03:37.889 | 35:03:28.823 | - | - |
| 24. | 8. | Lock Haven (C) | Duquesne (B) | C | B | Tyler Cox, Alex Nole, Scott Davern, Clayton Blose | Hunter Williams, Trevor Foley, Nathaniel Helfferich, Jacob VanHouten | 3:38.05 | 35:03:45.411 | - | - |
| 25. | 29. | Va. Military Institute (C) | Slippery Rock | C | B | Aidan Ball, Zachary Chase, Matt Harvey, Alex Midkiff | Philip Palmer, Eric Barto, Marc Megenhardt, Matt Hendrix | 31:03:38.09 | 35:03:28.823 | 840 | - |
| 26. | 33. | Walsh (B) | Cedarville (C) | B | C | Seth Wieland, Alex Bates, Kyle Denihan, Devon Gates | Steven Johnson, Jaquan Stuckey, Jaylen Jordan, Kyle Estep | 3:38.77 | 46:03:26.727 | - | - |
| 27. | 15. | California (Pa.) (D) | Duquesne | D | A | Steven Johnson, Jaquan Stuckey, Jaylen Jordan, Kyle Estep | Lamar Hargrove, Dominic Colvin, Reginald Mortel, Ishan Garrett | 56:03:40.6210 | 3:26.011 | - | - |
| 28. | 25. | Westminster (Pa.) | Ashland (C) | A | A | Anthony Yasko, Robert Brooks, Jake Dindak, Christian Friday | Steven Johnson, Jaquan Stuckey, Jaylen Jordan, Kyle Estep | 3:41.9422 | 31:03:38.09 | - | 9356 |
| 29. | 12. | Ashland (D) | Tiffin | D | C | Benjamin Herbert, Mike Navratil, Tommy Menyes, Aubrey Jordan | Marius Weber, Anthony Phillips, Travis McKinley, Michel Krempin | 32:03:44.1828 | 25:03:37.889 | - | 9356 |
| 30. | 15. | Wheeling Jesuit (B) | Wheeling Jesuit (B) | B | B | Brennan Comfort, Roland Rush, Brandon Porter, Jake Dull | Patrick Miller, Carl Sturges, Paul Blinn, Frank Dallago | 35:03:45.411 | 35:03:45.411 | - | - |
| 31. | 33. | Duquesne | California (Pa.) | A | A | Dino Andrade, Bryan Culley, Alex Schaffstall, Frazee Sutphen | Craig Dougherty, Paul Sonego, Joseph Mikulin, Sherman Kortze | 3:46.2975 | 3:34.78 | 9356 | - |
| 32. | 31. | Washington and Jefferson | Cedarville (B) | A | A | Ronald Graf, Zach Perry, Frank Adamo, Matt Ridge | Mike Strein, Kyle Trinch, Tyler Pirilla, Mike Bryk | 17:03:47.128 | 46:03:26.727 | - | - |
| 33. | 20. | Indiana (Pa.) (C) | Cedarville | C | A | Andrew Morgan, Aaron Snook, Jack Iannuzzi, Dalton Trump | Isaac Beverly, Shaun Borland, Macerio Clark, Austin Davis | 3:51.01 | 3:46.2975 | - | - |
| 34. | 15. | Cedarville (C) | Cedarville (B) | C | A | Jared Vega, Nathan Wright, Bradley Wisler, Jor-el Sanchez | Jack Felt, Justin Elchynski, Paul Stults, Matt Guiod | 59:03:53.4640 | 3:28.42 | - | - |
