| 1. | 2. | Bucknell | Shippensburg | A | B | Louis Tobias, Andrew Garcia-Garrison, John Westwood, David Frering | Braden Bruning, Dan Dreeman, Tom Kehl, Nicholas Gibson | 7:57.3500 | 8:24.9832 | 106 | - |
| 2. | 1. | Shippensburg | Bucknell (B) | A | A | Braden Bruning, Dan Dreeman, Tom Kehl, Nicholas Gibson | Ben Burgess, Christopher D'Aliso, Cody Haupt, Christopher Sisto | 7:58.68 | 8:58.4653 | 181 | 76 |
| 3. | 1. | Mount St. Mary's | Shippensburg | A | A | Sean Fritz, Christopher Eltringham, Jesse Langton, Kody Wilson | Louis Tobias, Andrew Garcia-Garrison, John Westwood, David Frering | 8:05.960 | 8:58.4653 | 76 | 76 |
| 4. | 1. | Chicago State | Saint Francis (Pa.) | A | A | Charles Blackhawk, David Prchal, DeShaunte Lewis, DiJon Smith | Braden Bruning, Dan Dreeman, Tom Kehl, Nicholas Gibson | 8:24.9832 | 7:58.68 | 241 | 181 |
| 5. | 4. | Saint Francis (Pa.) | Mount St. Mary's | A | B | Shaun Allen, Jamaal Booker, Kyle Penney, Thomas Somerville | Braden Bruning, Dan Dreeman, Tom Kehl, Nicholas Gibson | 8:37.903 | 8:24.9832 | 942 | 76 |
| 6. | 1. | Bucknell (B) | Mount St. Mary's | B | A | Ben Burgess, Christopher D'Aliso, Cody Haupt, Christopher Sisto | Shaun Allen, Jamaal Booker, Kyle Penney, Thomas Somerville | 8:58.4653 | 7:58.68 | - | 106 |
