| 1. | 5. | Memphis | DePaul | A | A | Antaun Andrews, LaForrest Church, Alex Klatt, Chris Walker | Mitch Baum, Jamison Dale, Chandler Diffee, Elijah Olige | 3:12.9754 | 1:03:20.27 |
| 2. | 5. | DePaul | Western Kentucky (C) | A | A | Charles Bottoms, Jarvis Hill, Isaac Walker, Sebastian Feyersinger | Quamel Prince, Jason Griffin, Jontue McDowell, Desmond Tanner | 3:14.179 | 19:03:33.286 |
| 3. | 11. | Loyola (Ill.) (B) | Western Kentucky (C) | B | B | Mitch Baum, Jamison Dale, Chandler Diffee, Elijah Olige | Grant Swinton, Vincent Wyatt, Jonathan Hayden, Corey Parks | 53:03:14.70 | DNF |
| 4. | 5. | Western Kentucky | Oakland (B) | A | B | Kyree King , Julius Morris, Michael Songore, Ja'Karyus Redwine | Graham Stecz, Cory Carter, Tim Vestuto, Andrew Shroyer | 3:16.019 | 3:12.9754 |
| 5. | | Belmont | DePaul | A | A | Caleb Corprew, Andrew Garcia, Travis Case, Christian Crenshaw | Michael Carey, Jason Kimmet, Luis Hanssler, Lucas Miller | 17:03:18.142 | 3:14.179 |
| 6. | 1. | Memphis (B) | Memphis | B | B | Michael Carey, Jason Kimmet, Luis Hanssler, Lucas Miller | Michael Carey, Jason Kimmet, Luis Hanssler, Lucas Miller | 3:19.64 | 53:03:14.70 |
| 7. | 3. | Miami (Ohio) | Loyola (Ill.) (B) | A | A | Adam Bodrick, Vinnie Minosky, Jake Owens, Matt Owens | Mitch Baum, Jamison Dale, Chandler Diffee, Elijah Olige | 1:03:20.27 | 3:16.019 |
| 8. | 9. | Western Kentucky (B) | Oakland (B) | B | A | Grant Swinton, Vincent Wyatt, Jonathan Hayden, Corey Parks | Caleb Corprew, Andrew Garcia, Travis Case, Christian Crenshaw | 3:21.016 | 3:19.64 |
| 9. | 4. | Oakland | Western Kentucky | A | B | Austin Davis, Zack Joyce, Timothy Pfund , Christopher Scott | Mitch Baum, Jamison Dale, Chandler Diffee, Elijah Olige | 36:03:22.27 | DNS |
| 10. | 1. | Oakland (B) | Tennessee St. | B | A | Geoffrey Williston, Brandon Davis, Glen Scott, Tre Brown | Keenon Laine, Aaron Stevens, Emmanuel Dasor, Ventavius Sears | 25:03:27.523 | 17:03:18.142 |
| 11. | 1. | Western Kentucky (C) | Loyola (Ill.) | C | A | Keenon Laine, Aaron Stevens, Emmanuel Dasor, Ventavius Sears | LeRon Norton, Peter Archibald, Samuel Urben, Jake Mazanke | 19:03:33.286 | 3:14.179 |
| | 11. | Loyola (Ill.) | Belmont | A | A | LeRon Norton, Peter Archibald, Samuel Urben, Jake Mazanke | Grant Swinton, Vincent Wyatt, Jonathan Hayden, Corey Parks | DNF | 3:16.019 |
| | 11. | Butler | Western Kentucky (B) | A | A | Graham Stecz, Cory Carter, Tim Vestuto, Andrew Shroyer | Charles Bottoms, Jarvis Hill, Isaac Walker, Sebastian Feyersinger | DNS | 3:19.64 |
| | 9. | Tennessee St. | Loyola (Ill.) | A | B | Quamel Prince, Jason Griffin, Jontue McDowell, Desmond Tanner | Antaun Andrews, LaForrest Church, Alex Klatt, Chris Walker | DNS | 25:03:27.523 |
