| 1. | 12. | Campbell | Christopher Newport | Meshack Kipruto, Collin Cooper, Graeme Fisher, Kelvin Kirui | Alec Thibodeaux, Joshua Bishop, Tyler Denlinger, Jared Nisly | 10:00.53 | DNS |
| 2. | 13. | Christopher Newport | Johns Hopkins | Zachary Campbell, Cullen Monahan, Cavanaugh McGaw, Jeffrey Dover | Jonathan Moore, Jamel Davis, DeAndre Petty, Cameron Berryhill | 10:02.8327 | 10:02.8327 |
| 3. | 9. | North Carolina | Bethune-Cookman | Alex Milligan, Harrison Young, Noah Shore, Logan Carroll | Alex Milligan, Harrison Young, Noah Shore, Logan Carroll | 51:10:04.742 | 50:10:16.056 |
| 4. | 5. | Mount Olive | Pfeiffer | Brady Deaner, Johnny Middlebrooks, Jacob Urys, Jonathan Dahlke | Meshack Kipruto, Collin Cooper, Graeme Fisher, Kelvin Kirui | 10:06.0090 | 51:10:04.742 |
| 5. | 8. | Johns Hopkins | Johns Hopkins | Scott Pourshalchi, Jesse Poore, Brett Wolfinger, Tom Pavarini | Brandon Raleigh, Justin Brooks, Harold Smith, Christian Noble | 10:07.542 | 10:47.695 |
| 6. | 6. | Lee (Tenn.) | Cumberlands | Brandon Raleigh, Justin Brooks, Harold Smith, Christian Noble | Benjamin Doiron, Liam Purdy, Matthew Rainey, Alaeldin Tirba | 50:10:16.056 | DNS |
| 7. | 6. | Eastern Mennonite | Johns Hopkins | Alec Thibodeaux, Joshua Bishop, Tyler Denlinger, Jared Nisly | Scott Pourshalchi, Jesse Poore, Brett Wolfinger, Tom Pavarini | 10:36.6298 | 50:10:16.056 |
| 8. | 6. | Montreat | Campbell | Daniel Lancaster, Marcus Medina-Artis, Elijah Mitchell, Brien Lancaster | Benjamin Doiron, Liam Purdy, Matthew Rainey, Alaeldin Tirba | 4:10:42.36 | 10:47.695 |
| 9. | | Charleston Southern | Limestone | Keith Terry, Josiah Scarlett, Brandon Damon, Jeryk Wilson | Daniel Lancaster, Marcus Medina-Artis, Elijah Mitchell, Brien Lancaster | 50:10:43.39 | 47:11:06.951 |
| 10. | | Bethune-Cookman | Mount Olive | Jonathan Moore, Jamel Davis, DeAndre Petty, Cameron Berryhill | Alex Milligan, Harrison Young, Noah Shore, Logan Carroll | 10:47.695 | DNS |
| 11. | 6. | Cumberlands | Bethune-Cookman | Travis O'Dell, Nathan Hepburn, James MacPherson, Sam Beal | Zachary Campbell, Cullen Monahan, Cavanaugh McGaw, Jeffrey Dover | 50:10:48.2259 | 50:10:16.056 |
| 12. | | Limestone | Lee (Tenn.) | Corey Ross, Nelson Stalling, Michael Darazi, Scott Swing | Travis O'Dell, Nathan Hepburn, James MacPherson, Sam Beal | 48:10:50.88 | DNS |
| 13. | 10. | Pfeiffer | Bethune-Cookman | Chris Laughlin, Cody Kelly, Curtis Freeman, Brandon Boyd | Alec Thibodeaux, Joshua Bishop, Tyler Denlinger, Jared Nisly | 47:11:06.951 | 10:02.8327 |
| | 4. | American | Christopher Newport | Benjamin Doiron, Liam Purdy, Matthew Rainey, Alaeldin Tirba | Zachary Campbell, Cullen Monahan, Cavanaugh McGaw, Jeffrey Dover | DNS | 48:10:50.88 |
| | 1. | Benedict | Limestone | Noah Prevard, Antoine Locklin, Stephan Richardson, Haregot Gebreyesus | Chris Laughlin, Cody Kelly, Curtis Freeman, Brandon Boyd | DNS | 47:11:06.951 |
