| 1. | 3. | Otterbein | Wilmington (Ohio) | Jacob Thompson, Michael Rennette, Bill Daily, Trevor Dilley | Cameron Phelps, Aaron Koch, Taton Bertsch, Evan Whitaker | 19:10:37.62 | 41:11:38.56 | 7510 | 908 |
| 2. | 2. | Mount Union | Mount Union | John Wahlie, Mitchell Milem, Hunter Probert, Alex Bryan | John Wahlie, Mitchell Milem, Hunter Probert, Alex Bryan | 21:10:38.53 | 11:30.46 | 908 | 2440 |
| 3. | 3. | John Carroll | Ohio Northern | Patrick McGuire, Zack Modzelewski, Jarrod McDowell, Pat White | Jacob Thompson, Michael Rennette, Bill Daily, Trevor Dilley | 10:39.45 | 41:11:38.56 | 7269 | 2440 |
| 4. | 7. | Ohio Northern | Otterbein | Andrew Shelton, Cody Benny, Sam Krabacher, Jordan Green | Andrew Murray, Zachary Fuhrer, Logan Skolosh, Doug McIntire | 10:39.7883 | 21:10:38.53 | 0458 | 3131 |
| 5. | 1. | Baldwin Wallace | Ohio Northern | Jose Reynoso, Brandon Cole, David Prather, Joe Juda | Andrew Murray, Zachary Fuhrer, Logan Skolosh, Doug McIntire | 10:47.604 | 41:11:38.56 | 2440 | 0458 |
| 6. | 8. | Wilmington (Ohio) | Mount Union | Cameron Phelps, Aaron Koch, Taton Bertsch, Evan Whitaker | Patrick McGuire, Zack Modzelewski, Jarrod McDowell, Pat White | 40:10:58.8377 | 40:10:58.8377 | 0236 | 7269 |
| 7. | 5. | Heidelberg | Mount Union | Hunter Greenman, Mitch Luken, Eric Peterson, Dylan Wiechart | Patrick McGuire, Zack Modzelewski, Jarrod McDowell, Pat White | 11:02.532 | 10:39.7883 | 23 | 3131 |
| 8. | 3. | Capital | Baldwin Wallace | Grant Ward, Cole Williams, Jonas Pyle, Nathan Hutchins | Hunter Greenman, Mitch Luken, Eric Peterson, Dylan Wiechart | 11:30.46 | 10:47.604 | 3131 | 7510 |
| 9. | 3. | Muskingum | Baldwin Wallace | Andrew Murray, Zachary Fuhrer, Logan Skolosh, Doug McIntire | John Wahlie, Mitchell Milem, Hunter Probert, Alex Bryan | 41:11:38.56 | 10:39.7883 | - | - |
