| 1. | 4. | St. Francis (Ill.) | St. Francis (Ill.) | Moses Biosah, Elihu Young, Kaizer Giddie, Brandon Ruffin | Peter Van Os, Logan Pinkerton, Elliot Kim, Andrew Daghfal | 3:15.540 | 28:03:17.2137 |
| 2. | 7. | Olivet | St. Francis (Ill.) | Noah Bailey, Tyler Peck, Chris Womack, Kyle McDowell | Preston Whaley, Andrew Young, Jose Franco, Tyler Ramsey | 28:03:17.2137 | 3:19.96 |
| 3. | 1. | Webster | St. Francis (Ill.) | Carson Gross, Elijah Perez, Jacob Ridenhour, Brandyn Robinson | Carson Gross, Elijah Perez, Jacob Ridenhour, Brandyn Robinson | 29:03:18.307 | 3:19.96 |
| 4. | 1. | Olivet Nazarene | Olivet Nazarene | Justin Wolz, Ethan Hodel, Tracker Harris, Brady Williams | Dillon O'Loughlin, Elliott Paintsil, Benjamin Chaimberg, Tyson Miller | 41:03:18.480 | 3:15.540 |
| 5. | 1. | U. of Chicago | U. of Chicago | Dillon O'Loughlin, Elliott Paintsil, Benjamin Chaimberg, Tyson Miller | Justin Wolz, Ethan Hodel, Tracker Harris, Brady Williams | 3:19.2244 | 3:15.540 |
| 6. | 6. | Wabash | St. Francis (Ill.) | Preston Whaley, Andrew Young, Jose Franco, Tyler Ramsey | Moses Biosah, Elihu Young, Kaizer Giddie, Brandon Ruffin | 3:19.96 | 41:03:18.480 |
| 7. | 6. | Wheaton (Ill.) | Webster | Peter Van Os, Logan Pinkerton, Elliot Kim, Andrew Daghfal | Preston Whaley, Andrew Young, Jose Franco, Tyler Ramsey | 3:27.9214 | 41:03:18.480 |
