| 1. | 1. | 13. | Rochester | St. John Fisher | SUNY Geneseo | A | A | C | Wells Coalfleet, Gabe Lundy, Mark Westman, Dokata Kosi Banchale | Lucas Sharron, Josh Tomaka, Devan Ketcham, Patrick Healy | Ryan Dwyer, Joey Saxton, Nico Bellavia, Kieran Sheridan | 3:20.7959 | 32:03:36.89 | 3:39.6837 | 10 | 10 | 03 |
| 2. | | 8. | Cortland St. | Williams | Hamilton (B) | A | A | C | Noah Serrette, Richard Samuels, Jaheim Dotson, Coltrane Goring | Lucas Sharron, Josh Tomaka, Devan Ketcham, Patrick Healy | Sam Carter, Andy Frank, Evan Jones, Nate Oczkowski | 3:23.5606 | 3:45.671 | 3:39.6837 | 39804 | - | 39804 |
| 3. | 7. | 14. | SUNY Geneseo | Nazareth (B) | Rochester (C) | A | B | A | Ryan Dwyer, Joey Saxton, Nico Bellavia, Kieran Sheridan | Jason Kauppila, Samuel Gordon, Conor Courtney, Samuel Pomerantz | Sean Gublo, Leo Orsini, Blaine Doyle, Collin Gwilt | 3:25.05 | 3:39.6837 | 3:35.60 | 14615 | 3570 | 3570 |
| 4. | 10. | 7. | Ithaca | Rochester (B) | Hamilton | A | A | A | Sam Carter, Andy Frank, Evan Jones, Nate Oczkowski | Corey Jones, Nicholas Ng, Hugo Frost, Lucas Wright | Wells Coalfleet, Gabe Lundy, Mark Westman, Dokata Kosi Banchale | 3:28.148 | 3:39.6837 | 3:35.60 | 3570 | 03 | 140 |
| 5. | 2. | 6. | Williams | Nazareth | Ithaca | A | A | A | Cole O'Flaherty, Ethan Cooper, Nolan Holley, Kevin LaFleche | Trent McGuire, Jonathon White, Chance Singleton, Chris Petraskie | John Goldszer, Liam Higgins, Brendan Murphy, Peter Moller | 3:28.734 | 55:03:56.1825 | 3:25.05 | 140 | 3570 | - |
| 6. | 10. | 12. | SUNY Geneseo (B) | Susquehanna | Hamilton (B) | B | A | A | John Goldszer, Liam Higgins, Brendan Murphy, Peter Moller | Wells Coalfleet, Gabe Lundy, Mark Westman, Dokata Kosi Banchale | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | 3:29.191 | 3:39.6837 | 51:03:49.502 | - | - | - |
| 7. | 16. | 9. | Hamilton | Hamilton (C) | St. John Fisher | A | B | A | Corey Jones, Nicholas Ng, Hugo Frost, Lucas Wright | Sam Carter, Andy Frank, Evan Jones, Nate Oczkowski | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | 40:03:29.6112 | 55:03:56.1825 | 32:03:36.89 | 03 | 39804 | 39804 |
| 8. | 12. | 9. | Susquehanna | Rochester (C) | Hamilton (C) | A | A | A | Trent McGuire, Jonathon White, Chance Singleton, Chris Petraskie | Sam Carter, Andy Frank, Evan Jones, Nate Oczkowski | Sean Gublo, Leo Orsini, Blaine Doyle, Collin Gwilt | 3:30.33 | 3:20.7959 | 24:03:33.5104 | 2 | - | - |
| 9. | 14. | 4. | Cortland St. (C) | Hamilton (C) | Hamilton (C) | C | A | B | Philippe Louis-Juste, Cameron Szabo, Ryan Konotopskyj, David Melick | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | Cole O'Flaherty, Ethan Cooper, Nolan Holley, Kevin LaFleche | 50:03:33.3904 | 50:03:33.3904 | 3:28.148 | - | 140 | 10 |
| 10. | 5. | 14. | Rochester (B) | Susquehanna | Ithaca | B | A | A | Sean Gublo, Leo Orsini, Blaine Doyle, Collin Gwilt | Sean Gublo, Leo Orsini, Blaine Doyle, Collin Gwilt | Wells Coalfleet, Gabe Lundy, Mark Westman, Dokata Kosi Banchale | 24:03:33.5104 | DNF | 3:35.60 | - | 10 | 14615 |
| 11. | | 1. | St. John Fisher | Hamilton (B) | Hamilton (C) | A | B | A | Grant Stokoe, Myles Anderson, Ryan Allen, Fred Owen | Philippe Louis-Juste, Cameron Szabo, Ryan Konotopskyj, David Melick | John Goldszer, Liam Higgins, Brendan Murphy, Peter Moller | 3:35.60 | 3:35.60 | 3:25.05 | 10 | - | 03 |
| 12. | 16. | 15. | Williams (B) | Williams (B) | Hamilton (C) | B | A | A | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | 32:03:36.89 | 3:29.191 | 3:45.671 | - | 03 | - |
| 13. | | 16. | Nazareth | SUNY Geneseo (B) | Hamilton (C) | A | B | C | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | 3:39.6837 | 3:28.734 | DNF | - | 39804 | 03 |
| 14. | 13. | 3. | Rochester (C) | Williams (B) | Cortland St. (B) | C | A | A | Evan Botelho, Joshua Agyarko Jr., Jason Cobham, Aaron Messina | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | 3:43.285 | 3:30.33 | 32:03:36.89 | - | - | - |
| 15. | 15. | 12. | Hamilton (B) | Cortland St. (C) | Hamilton (C) | B | A | B | James Reynolds, Matthew Sinning, Jacob Colangelo, Francis Zuroski | John Goldszer, Liam Higgins, Brendan Murphy, Peter Moller | Jett Ballantyne, Karol Regula, Sam Schraver, Chris Bassett | 3:45.671 | 3:39.6837 | 24:03:33.5104 | - | 3570 | - |
| 16. | 16. | 9. | Nazareth (B) | Hamilton (B) | Cortland St. | B | A | B | Lucas Sharron, Josh Tomaka, Devan Ketcham, Patrick Healy | Cole O'Flaherty, Ethan Cooper, Nolan Holley, Kevin LaFleche | Matt Johnson, Mike Welch, Calvin Garnes, Jason Hall | 51:03:49.502 | 3:30.33 | 3:35.60 | - | - | 10 |
| 17. | | 7. | Hamilton (C) | Susquehanna | Cortland St. (C) | C | A | C | Jason Kauppila, Samuel Gordon, Conor Courtney, Samuel Pomerantz | Jason Kauppila, Samuel Gordon, Conor Courtney, Samuel Pomerantz | James Reynolds, Matthew Sinning, Jacob Colangelo, Francis Zuroski | 55:03:56.1825 | 3:39.6837 | 40:03:29.6112 | - | 14615 | - |
| | 3. | 6. | Cortland St. (B) | Rochester (C) | Hamilton (C) | B | B | B | Alhagie-Sori Sesay, James Forte, Clayton Santiago, Nolan Vest | Evan Botelho, Joshua Agyarko Jr., Jason Cobham, Aaron Messina | Grant Stokoe, Myles Anderson, Ryan Allen, Fred Owen | DNF | 3:23.5606 | 55:03:56.1825 | - | - | 3570 |
