| 1. | 1. | John Carroll | Wilmington (Ohio) | Patrick McGuire, Mike Shipman, Pat White, Ian Pierson | Jordan Green, Hunter Kesler, Andrew Shelton, Sam Krabacher | 49:10:27.63 | 10:39.533 | 2610 | 544 |
| 2. | 5. | Otterbein | Ohio Northern | Cal Yackin, Nathan Forney, Gage Beireis, Jacob Thompson | Jordan Green, Hunter Kesler, Andrew Shelton, Sam Krabacher | 21:10:28.28 | 10:34.7112 | 298 | 544 |
| 3. | 5. | Wilmington (Ohio) | Wilmington (Ohio) | Taton Bertsch, Aaron Koch, Josh Cyrus, Simon Heys | Zach Brown, Grant Ward, Tyler Gunderson, Alex Hansel | 10:34.7112 | 22:10:45.727 | 6 | 20 |
| 4. | 2. | Mount Union | Heidelberg | Hunter Probert, Justin Knoch, Alex Bryan, John Wahlie | Cal Yackin, Nathan Forney, Gage Beireis, Jacob Thompson | 10:39.533 | 10:34.7112 | 544 | 0511 |
| 5. | 6. | Ohio Northern | Mount Union | Jordan Green, Hunter Kesler, Andrew Shelton, Sam Krabacher | Cal Yackin, Nathan Forney, Gage Beireis, Jacob Thompson | 35:10:44.00 | 10:34.7112 | 4 | 298 |
| 6. | 6. | Heidelberg | John Carroll | David Drushal, Mitch Luken, Hunter Greenman, Dylan Wiechart | Patrick McGuire, Mike Shipman, Pat White, Ian Pierson | 22:10:45.727 | 35:10:44.00 | 3 | - |
| 7. | 6. | Baldwin Wallace | Capital | Zach Justus, Alexander Burkhammer, Joe Juda, David Prather | Taton Bertsch, Aaron Koch, Josh Cyrus, Simon Heys | 35:11:00.2607 | 10:34.7112 | 20 | 544 |
| 8. | 1. | Capital | Capital | Zach Brown, Grant Ward, Tyler Gunderson, Alex Hansel | Jordan Green, Hunter Kesler, Andrew Shelton, Sam Krabacher | 13:11:15.4225 | 13:11:15.4225 | 0511 | 3 |
| 9. | 9. | Muskingum | Wilmington (Ohio) | Doug McIntire, Logan Skolosh, John Franz, Luke Howald | Zach Brown, Grant Ward, Tyler Gunderson, Alex Hansel | 11:46.429 | 49:10:27.63 | - | 0511 |
