| 1. | 5. | Marian (Ind.) | Grace | Kyle Liwanag, Nathan Blyly, Drew Thornton, Howard Hendricks | Colin Gaines, Clayton Slemmons, Justis Paul, Garrett Gemmaka | 7:46.436 | 1:08:18.818 | 10 | 10 |
| 2. | 7. | Grace | Marian (Ind.) | Isaac Beatty, Luke Smith, Kyle Smith, Maurice Macklin Jr. | Isaac Beatty, Luke Smith, Kyle Smith, Maurice Macklin Jr. | 7:48.7661 | 7:46.436 | 805 | 85 |
| 3. | 6. | Spring Arbor | Huntington | Timothy Nelson, Tommee Smith, Trent Smith, Max Whittredge | Kyle Liwanag, Nathan Blyly, Drew Thornton, Howard Hendricks | 7:52.23 | 9:08:55.142 | 16 | 85 |
| 4. | 3. | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Spring Arbor | Colin Gaines, Clayton Slemmons, Justis Paul, Garrett Gemmaka | Matthew Hyter, Justin Edwards, Logan Busz, Graham Johnson | 43:07:53.3327 | 7:48.7661 | 85 | 16 |
| 5. | 2. | Bethel (Ind.) | Bethel (Ind.) | Trevor Miller, Avery Richardson, Aden Burke, Kole Hanke | Trevor Miller, Avery Richardson, Aden Burke, Kole Hanke | 1:08:18.818 | 7:46.436 | 349 | 349 |
| 6. | 6. | Indiana Wesleyan | Grace | Noah Shigley, Logan Fullenkamp, Quinton Huggett, Kenny Erow | Kyle Liwanag, Nathan Blyly, Drew Thornton, Howard Hendricks | 10:08:24.0470 | 10:08:24.0470 | 133 | 10 |
| 7. | 2. | Huntington | Grace | Matthew Hyter, Justin Edwards, Logan Busz, Graham Johnson | Matthew Hyter, Justin Edwards, Logan Busz, Graham Johnson | 9:08:55.142 | 7:46.436 | 6275 | 6275 |
