| 1. | 4. | 2. | 2. | Rutgers | York (N.Y.) | Rutgers | York (N.Y.) | A | B | A | A | Shanelle Colmon, Sydney Hawkins, Aliya Harrison, Dennisha Page | Dolce McPherson, Mandana Vouillemin, Rushellee Jones, Tatyana McKenzie | Brooklyn Chestnut, Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Leah Anderson | Shanelle Colmon, Sydney Hawkins, Aliya Harrison, Dennisha Page | 23:01:38.2613 | 23:01:38.2613 | 2:00.181 | 1:59.030 |
| 2. | 4. | 3. | 2. | St. John's | Rutgers | St. John's (B) | New Jersey City | A | A | A | A | Brooklyn Chestnut, Avon Samuels, Skyy Diop, Leah Anderson | Dolce McPherson, Mandana Vouillemin, Rushellee Jones, Tatyana McKenzie | Shanelle Colmon, Sydney Hawkins, Aliya Harrison, Dennisha Page | Destiny Scott, Charlia Webb, Jaylene Coye, Taylor Bellmon | 1:38.957 | 1:38.957 | 2:00.181 | 1:43.521 |
| 3. | 1. | 1. | 1. | St. John's (B) | St. John's (B) | New Jersey City | St. John's (B) | B | A | A | A | Dolce McPherson, Mandana Vouillemin, Rushellee Jones, Tatyana McKenzie | Dolce McPherson, Mandana Vouillemin, Rushellee Jones, Tatyana McKenzie | Dolce McPherson, Mandana Vouillemin, Rushellee Jones, Tatyana McKenzie | Nyla Boyd, Tiffany Ortiz, Ashley Adames, Arame Diouf | 1:43.521 | 1:59.030 | 1:43.521 | 23:01:38.2613 |
| 4. | 2. | 1. | 3. | New Jersey City | York (N.Y.) | York (N.Y.) | Rutgers | A | B | B | A | Nyla Boyd, Tiffany Ortiz, Ashley Adames, Arame Diouf | Destiny Scott, Charlia Webb, Jaylene Coye, Taylor Bellmon | Destiny Scott, Charlia Webb, Jaylene Coye, Taylor Bellmon | Shanelle Colmon, Sydney Hawkins, Aliya Harrison, Dennisha Page | 1:59.030 | 2:00.181 | 1:38.957 | 23:01:38.2613 |
| 5. | 2. | 4. | 1. | York (N.Y.) | Rutgers | New Jersey City | St. John's (B) | A | B | A | A | Destiny Scott, Charlia Webb, Jaylene Coye, Taylor Bellmon | Destiny Scott, Charlia Webb, Jaylene Coye, Taylor Bellmon | Nyla Boyd, Tiffany Ortiz, Ashley Adames, Arame Diouf | Shanelle Colmon, Sydney Hawkins, Aliya Harrison, Dennisha Page | 2:00.181 | 2:00.181 | 2:00.181 | 23:01:38.2613 |
