| 1) | Rollins, Broncho | Fredonia | 4.86m (03/02-03/03) | 4.85m (02/26) | 4.75m (02/17) | 4.73m (02/04) | 4.71m (03/02-03/03) | 4.70m (02/26) | 4.70m (01/27-01/28) | 4.65m (02/11) |
| 2) | Burish, Jeremiah | Wis.-La Crosse | 4.86m (03/02) | 4.85m (02/17) | 4.73m (02/10) | 4.70m (02/17) | 4.66m (02/03) | 4.64m (02/24-02/25) | 4.60m (03/03) | 4.58m (02/10) |
| 3) | Negus, John | Wis.-Stout | 4.86m (03/02) | 4.80m (01/21) | 4.79m (02/24-02/25) | 4.75m (02/18) | 4.71m (03/02) | 4.68m (02/03) | 4.65m (01/21) | 4.64m (02/24-02/25) |
| 4) | Bilka, Dylan | Penn State-Behrend | 4.86m (03/02-03/03) | 4.73m (02/04) | 4.71m (03/02-03/03) | 4.58m (02/04) | 4.56m (03/02-03/03) | 4.43m (02/04) | 4.41m (03/02-03/03) | 4.40m (01/21) |