| 1) | Reiner, Annie | James Madison | 2:06.54 (05/11-05/13) | 2:07.54 (05/11-05/13) | 2:08.75 (04/14) | 2:10.02 (05/04-05/05) | 2:11.37 (05/04-05/05) |
| 2) | Borge, Martine | Arkansas | 2:06.54 (04/20-04/21) | 2:07.67 (05/10-05/13) | 2:07.76 (04/06-04/07) | 2:09.35 (04/25-04/28) | 2:11.26 (05/10-05/13) |
| 3) | Spencer, Ahlivia | Louisville | 2:06.54 (05/04-05/06) | 2:08.40 (05/04-05/06) | 2:08.75 (04/14) | 2:09.91 (04/20) | 2:10.57 (04/07) |