| 1) | Smith, Korey | BYU | 52.63 (04/24-04/27) | 52.64 (03/22-03/23) | 52.67 (04/24-04/27) | 52.88 (05/10-05/12) | 54.99 (03/14-03/16) | 58.25 (04/05-04/06) | ||
| 2) | Villines, Jesse | Idaho | 52.63 (05/08-05/11) | 52.68 (05/03-05/04) | 52.70 (05/08-05/11) | 52.89 (04/27) | 53.64 (04/20) | 54.77 (04/12-04/13) | 56.12 (04/06) | 56.26 (03/21-03/22) |
| 3) | Shaw, Arqeil | Indiana State | 52.63 (05/10-05/12) | 52.78 (05/10-05/12) | 53.14 (05/03) | 53.63 (03/29-03/30) | 54.16 (04/06) | 54.99 (04/11-04/13) | ||
| 4) | Pugh, Dennis | Florida A&M | 52.63 (05/02-05/04) | 53.01 (04/27) | 53.55 (05/02-05/04) | 53.70 (04/12-04/13) | 54.19 (03/15-03/16) | 55.23 (04/20) |