| 1) | McClafferty, Nate | Duke | 3:46.06 (04/18-04/20) | 3:47.41 (04/18-04/20) | 3:47.93 (05/10-05/11) | 3:52.10 (03/29-03/30) | 3:55.14 (04/05-04/06) | 3:57.73 (05/05) | 4:00.11 (03/22-03/23) |
| 2) | Wolfe, John Spencer | North Carolina St. | 3:46.06 (05/10) | 3:47.60 (04/18-04/20) | 3:50.96 (04/18-04/20) | 3:51.64 (05/05) | 3:53.72 (03/22-03/23) |