| 1) | LaRocca, Daniel | Illinois Wesleyan | 4.70m (05/17) | 4.66m (05/09-05/10) | 4.60m (04/20) | 4.58m (05/03-05/04) | 4.55m (05/17) | 4.53m (05/16-05/17) | 4.51m (05/09-05/10) | 4.45m (04/20) |
| 2) | Wisener, John | Bates | 4.70m (05/09-05/11) | 4.65m (05/02-05/04) | 4.65m (05/09-05/11) | 4.51m (05/16-05/17) | 4.50m (03/29-03/30) | 4.50m (04/20) | 4.50m (05/09-05/11) | 4.45m (04/13) |
| 3) | Schreck, Benjamin | MIT | 4.70m (05/09-05/11) | 4.65m (05/09-05/11) | 4.65m (05/02-05/04) | 4.50m (05/09-05/11) | 4.30m (04/27) | 4.15m (04/27) | 4.00m (04/06) | 3.85m (04/06) |
| 4) | Nakanishi, Brad | Tufts | 4.70m (05/09-05/11) | 4.65m (05/09-05/11) | 4.55m (04/06) | 4.55m (04/20) | 4.51m (05/16-05/17) | 4.50m (05/09-05/11) | 4.50m (05/02-05/04) | 4.40m (04/06) |
| 5) | Dahleiden, Cody | Fredonia | 4.70m (05/10) | 4.65m (04/19-04/20) | 4.55m (05/10) | 4.52m (04/06) | 4.50m (04/19-04/20) | 4.50m (05/03-05/04) | 4.50m (04/27) | 4.37m (04/06) |