| 1) | Saylor, Christopher | Otterbein | 4.58m (02/28-03/01) | 4.57m (02/15) | 4.50m (02/08) | 4.43m (02/28-03/01) | 4.42m (02/15) | 4.42m (02/08) | 4.28m (02/28-03/01) | 4.27m (01/18) |
| 2) | Fox, Tim | Muskingum | 4.58m (02/28-03/01) | 4.55m (02/21) | 4.43m (02/28-03/01) | 4.42m (01/25) | 4.42m (12/07-12/08) | 4.42m (02/15) | 4.40m (02/21) | 4.28m (02/28-03/01) |
| 3) | Cole, Brendan | Wheaton (Ill.) | 4.58m (02/28-03/01) | 4.50m (02/28-03/01) | 4.45m (02/14-02/15) | 4.40m (02/28-03/01) | 4.30m (02/21) | 4.30m (02/28-03/01) | 4.30m (02/14-02/15) | 4.25m (02/07) |