| 1) | Sampson, Nolan | Buena Vista | 2.08m (03/28-03/29) | 2.08m (04/04-04/05) | 2.03m (04/04-04/05) | 2.03m (03/28-03/29) | 2.03m (04/11-04/12) | 2.00m (03/28-03/29) | 1.98m (04/11-04/12) | 1.98m (04/04-04/05) |
| 2) | Wallace, Rob | Monmouth (Ill.) | 2.08m (03/28-03/29) | 2.06m (05/03) | 2.03m (04/10-04/12) | 2.03m (03/28-03/29) | 2.02m (05/03) | 2.00m (03/28-03/29) | 2.00m (05/09-05/10) | 1.99m (05/03) |
| 3) | Jones, Nic | Thiel | 2.08m (04/25-04/26) | 2.05m (04/25-04/26) | 2.00m (04/17) | 2.00m (05/02) | 1.99m (04/25-04/26) | 1.98m (04/12) | 1.98m (05/09) | 1.95m (04/15) |
| 4) | Warren, George | Trinity (Tex.) | 2.08m (04/11-04/12) | 2.03m (04/11-04/12) | 2.01m (03/22) | 2.00m (05/02) | 2.00m (03/28) | 1.98m (04/04-04/05) | 1.98m (04/11-04/12) | 1.95m (05/02) |
| 5) | Cutler, Kevin | UMass Dartmouth | 2.08m (05/01-05/03) | 2.03m (05/01-05/03) | 2.01m (04/27) | 2.00m (05/08-05/10) | 1.98m (05/01-05/03) | 1.98m (04/19) | 1.98m (04/27) | 1.95m (05/08-05/10) |