| 1) | Bennett, Michael | U. of Chicago | 4.91m (05/08-05/09) | 4.90m (04/17) | 4.85m (04/17) | 4.81m (05/08-05/09) | 4.75m (04/05) | 4.67m (05/15-05/16) | 4.67m (04/17) | 4.66m (05/08-05/09) |
| 2) | Trkula, Gary | Wis.-La Crosse | 4.91m (04/05) | 4.81m (04/05) | 4.81m (05/09) | 4.81m (05/15) | 4.71m (04/05) | 4.69m (05/02-05/03) | 4.68m (04/11-04/12) | 4.66m (05/15) |
| 3) | Rohe, Rob | Wis.-La Crosse | 4.91m (04/05) | 4.81m (04/05) | 4.81m (05/09) | 4.71m (04/05) | 4.66m (05/09) | 4.56m (04/05) | 4.53m (04/11-04/12) | 4.51m (05/09) |
| 4) | Makous, Troy | Washington U. | 4.91m (05/08-05/09) | 4.81m (05/08-05/09) | 4.75m (04/05) | 4.75m (05/03) | 4.67m (05/15-05/16) | 4.66m (05/08-05/09) | 4.65m (03/28-03/29) | 4.60m (05/03) |
| 5) | Alaniva, Nick | Washington U. | 4.91m (05/08-05/09) | 4.81m (05/08-05/09) | 4.70m (04/11-04/12) | 4.66m (05/08-05/09) | 4.55m (04/11-04/12) | 4.51m (05/08-05/09) | 4.42m (04/18) | 4.42m (04/26-04/27) |