| 1) | Ogilvie, Nathaniel | RPI | 4.25m (02/27-02/28) | 4.25m (02/21) | 4.20m (02/27-02/28) | 4.15m (02/27-02/28) | 4.15m (01/24) | 4.10m (02/21) | 4.05m (02/27-02/28) | 4.05m (02/14) |
| 2) | Cornelius, Devin | St. John Fisher | 4.25m (03/13-03/14) | 4.20m (02/14) | 4.15m (03/13-03/14) | 4.15m (02/27-02/28) | 4.05m (02/14) | 4.05m (02/27-02/28) | 4.05m (03/13-03/14) | 3.95m (01/31-02/01) |
| 3) | Teboe, Brandon | Alfred State | 4.25m (12/06) | 4.20m (01/23-01/24) | 4.10m (12/06) | 3.95m (12/06) | 3.90m (01/23-01/24) | 3.80m (02/21) | ||
| 4) | Rice, Patrick | Rochester | 4.25m (02/27-02/28) | 4.15m (02/27-02/28) | 4.05m (02/27-02/28) | 3.95m (02/27-02/28) | 3.85m (02/27-02/28) | 3.75m (12/11) | 3.75m (02/27-02/28) | 3.55m (02/27-02/28) |