| 1) | Alaniva, Nick | Washington U. | 4.60m (01/31) | 4.60m (02/20) | 4.57m (01/17) | 4.45m (02/14) | 4.45m (01/31) | 4.45m (02/20) | 4.42m (01/24) | 4.42m (01/17) |
| 2) | Wolters, Lucas | Calvin | 4.60m (02/06) | 4.55m (02/28) | 4.55m (01/24) | 4.47m (03/06-03/07) | 4.45m (02/06) | 4.40m (02/28) | 3.85m (01/10) | |
| 3) | Hartman, Calvin | Ramapo | 4.60m (02/20) | 4.52m (03/06-03/07) | 4.50m (01/24) | 4.45m (02/07) | 4.40m (02/20) | 4.37m (03/06-03/07) | 4.35m (01/31-02/01) | 4.35m (02/26) |
| 4) | Rex, Kaci | Coast Guard | 4.60m (02/20-02/21) | 4.50m (02/20-02/21) | 4.45m (02/14) | 4.40m (02/20-02/21) | 4.30m (02/14) | 4.30m (02/20-02/21) | 4.20m (02/20-02/21) | 4.20m (02/27-02/28) |
| 5) | O'Dea, Brian | Lynchburg | 4.60m (03/01) | 4.50m (01/16-01/17) | 4.40m (12/03-12/04) | 4.35m (01/30-01/31) | 4.35m (01/16-01/17) | 4.35m (03/01) | 4.30m (02/08) | 4.25m (12/03-12/04) |
| 6) | Daniel, John | Trine | 4.60m (01/23-01/24) | 4.47m (03/06-03/07) | 4.45m (01/23-01/24) | 4.45m (02/06-02/07) | 4.41m (12/12) | 4.40m (01/30) | 4.40m (02/28) | 4.30m (01/23-01/24) |
| 7) | Kalning, Mitchell | Mount Union | 4.60m (12/05) | 4.46m (02/07) | 4.45m (12/05) | 4.43m (02/21) | 4.40m (01/24) | 4.31m (02/07) | 4.30m (12/05) | 4.28m (02/21) |
| 8) | Farrand, AJ | Nebraska Wesleyan | 4.60m (02/20-02/21) | 4.45m (02/20-02/21) | 4.45m (01/30-01/31) | 4.40m (01/17) | 4.38m (02/28) | 4.32m (02/07) | 4.30m (02/14) | 4.30m (02/20-02/21) |