| 1) James Madison | 3:50.24 (03/06) | 3:50.37 (02/13) | 3:54.84 (02/06) | 3:56.91 (01/16) | 4:03.73 (02/20) | 4:04.04 (01/08) | ||
| 2) Quinnipiac | 3:50.24 (12/06) | 3:55.16 (01/10) | 3:56.21 (02/21) | 3:56.67 (01/30) | 3:58.09 (01/23) | 3:58.29 (01/16) | 4:04.63 (02/07) | 4:06.37 (02/07) |