| 1) | Swenson, Sarah | Wesleyan | 58.34 (02/07) | 58.60 (02/20-02/21) | 59.40 (02/27-02/28) | 1:00.61 (01/17) | 1:02.93 (01/10) |
| 2) | Terry, Katelyn | Keene State | 58.34 (02/27-02/28) | 58.82 (02/14) | 58.90 (12/06) | 1:00.19 (01/11) | |
| 3) | McPadden, Micaela | Rhode Island | 58.34 (02/13-02/14) | 58.88 (02/07) | 59.07 (01/24) |