| 1) | Bolton, Cameron | Eastern Michigan | 21.14 (04/17-04/18) | 21.17 (05/14-05/16) | 21.36 (05/14-05/16) | 21.44 (04/09-04/11) |
| 2) | Bruton, LaMar | Ohio State | 21.14 (05/15-05/17) | 21.18 (05/01-05/02) | 21.46 (05/15-05/17) | |
| 3) | Chism, Eric | Mississippi Valley | 21.14 (04/24-04/26) | 21.50 (04/24-04/26) | 21.74 (04/10-04/11) |