| 1) | Ritz, Ben | Columbia | 3:46.31 (05/16) | 3:46.75 (05/01-05/02) | 3:47.50 (04/17-04/18) | 3:48.47 (04/11) | 3:50.98 (05/09-05/10) | 3:54.06 (04/03-04/04) |
| 2) | Mohn, Logan | St. Joseph's (Pa.) | 3:46.31 (05/15-05/17) | 3:49.67 (05/02-05/03) | 3:50.94 (04/17-04/18) | 3:51.11 (05/11) | 3:53.50 (04/02-04/04) | 3:57.45 (05/15-05/17) |