| 1) | Anaya, Austin | Adams State | 3:49.95 (05/10) | 3:50.87 (04/03-04/04) | 3:51.84 (04/17) | 3:52.52 (04/17-04/18) | 3:52.62 (05/01-05/03) | 3:56.40 (05/01-05/03) |
| 2) | Tesfai, Germay | Chico State | 3:49.95 (05/09) | 3:53.07 (04/10-04/11) | 3:56.26 (04/29-05/02) | 3:58.66 (04/17-04/18) | 3:58.76 (03/14) |