| 1) | Murphy, Grant | Emory | 3:50.91 (05/14-05/15) | 3:50.94 (04/25-04/26) | 3:58.01 (04/03-04/04) | 3:58.21 (03/27-03/28) | 4:03.20 (05/09) |
| 2) | Kerska, Garrett | Wis.-La Crosse | 3:50.91 (05/08) | 3:54.86 (05/01-05/02) | 3:57.59 (04/16-04/17) | 3:58.03 (04/03) | 3:58.03 (05/15) |